When developing an effective WordPress website with good conversion capabilities, speed is extremely important. In fact, the user will immediately ignore the website if it does not upload in 2 seconds. Although there are many tools to help speed up the website, the most effective way is to share the caching tool. Even so, choosing the right caching plugin can be a problem.

We already have a tutorial on how to delete WordPress cache , now we will compare the 2 most popular cache plugins so you can choose:

  1. W3 Total Cache : A solution has a lot of features related to managing the caching of a site
  2. WP Super Cache : A simpler but equally powerful solution suitable for large traffic sites

In this article, we will explain why using WordPress cache plugin is necessary. Next, we will closely compare all aspects between WP Super Cache and W3 Total Cache. Let the war begin!

Why you need to use cache plugins for WordPress sites

Before officially analyzing the WP Super Cache vs W3 Total Cache, we needed to clarify what caching is and how it can help your website. Basically, a ‘ cache’ is a temporary partition that can be accessed at high speed. It helps store newly used information, so it can be easily accessed again at a later time. Therefore, caching is used to display a static version of the website to visitors.

These are the reasons caching will benefit your website:

  • Significantly increase website speed and performance: Because the nature of caching is to help regular files can be accessed through a proxy cache, it is much faster than downloading the entire website directly from the server.
  • Reduce website bandwidth consumption: This means that it does not cause choking, or exceeds the bandwidth allowed (thus saving more bandwidth rent).
  • Make sure website content is always available: For example, if the site is down because the network connection is broken, cached content will still be visible to visitors.
  • Increase Search Engine Optimization (SEO) of the site:  Because search engines use speed as a ranking factor , reducing the latency of the site can increase the ranking of your website.
  • Reducing the load for your hosting server: In addition to increasing speed, this will also help to free up server memory.

Considering the outstanding advantages of caching, programmers have quickly created many WordPress caching plugins that you don’t know which way to choose. However, 2 of the plugins you can safely choose are WP Super Cache and W3 Total Cache because they have many flexible features. So let’s join us in examining the WP Super Cache solution with W3 Total Cache, to see which plugin is better for you guys.

WP Super Cache vs W3 Total Cache: Detailed comparison

Below, we will look at the differences between WP Super Cache vs W3 Total Cache. We also discuss issues such as installation, features, pricing and support.


Let’s get started first with WP Super Cache:

WP super cache plugin

WP Super Cache was created by Automattic , the company behind WordPress. It helps you create static HTML files so that the web server displays it to visitors. This solution is faster than handling WordPress PHP scripts , which are more expensive and take longer to process.

WP Super Cache has 3 methods for serving cached files. ‘Expert’, the fastest way, make sure the site works even if it suffers from a lot of traffic (very useful when your website needs to expand). The ‘Simple’ method is not as fast, but can have files stored in the dynamic still call area . The final method, ‘WP-Cache caching’, is primarily aimed at people who are logged in, helping them perform tasks on the site faster and safer.

READ  7 best marketing strategies for your business

WP Super Cache is simple, lightweight, and easy to configure, it is the first choice for those who are new to WordPress. It can also be synchronized with the Content Delivery Network (CDN) , which means you can speed up your site even further.

Now, we will introduce to W3 Total Cache:

W3 total cache

Like WP Super Cache, W3 Total Cache can be easily integrated with CDN. However, it saves bandwidth more because it also minifies and compressing your site files. The flexible compression and compression capability of this plugin also speeds up WordPress 10 times. It also has a feature that reduces page loading time, and also increases the user experience in the process.

W3 Total Cache is different from WP Super Cache in that it doesn’t need to know what the web host is using, it still acts as a reliable caching solution. WP Super Cache works better on weaker servers.

Because there are many features for minimizing JavaScript and Custom Style Sheet (CSS) , as well as the ability to object caching capabilities , W3 Total Cache is better suited for users who need advanced features. Especially for those who want to develop WordPress sites that are aimed at mobile users, because it also supports caching for Accelerated Mobile Pages (AMP) .

We will look specifically at the features between W3 Total Cache and WP Super Cache below. Now, let’s see what is the user-friendly level of each WordPress cache plugin.

Easy to use

Like any WordPress plugin, you can install WP Super Cache or W3 Total Cache by going to Plugins> Add New in the dashboard. Then find the name of that plugin. Click the Install Now button , and don’t forget the Activate plugin later:

install the wp super cache plugin and w3 total cache

After installation is complete, see how to configure W3 Total Cache.

You will see that after activating W3 Total Cache, a new menu called Performance will appear in the dashboard. To complete configuring the W3 total cache, you need to enter this item: Performance> General Settings , then adjust each setting on it. Click Save all settings for to apply your choice:

page to install w3 total cache

This process can cause you headaches, especially if you are new to handling caching. Luckily, W3 Total Cache has a FAQ page, which provides the best configuration techniques for your site.

In contrast, setting up WP Super Cache configuration is simpler. After installing and activating this plugin, go to  Settings> WP Super Cache. You will see two simple options to turn off or turn on caching. Click on Caching On button and select Update Status and finish:

configure wp super cache setting

In this part of the WP Super Cache vs W3 Total Cache, it is clear that WP super cache is better. However, because the WP super cache is not heavy on features, it is suitable for implementing simple caching for sites on weak servers.


Both plugins have powerful features to help improve server performance and user experience. The main difference between the two is how flexible each feature is, and how to configure each feature to suit the caching requirements.

Some key features of the W3 Total Cache plugin:

  • Minification for many types of file types (HTTP, CSS, JavaScript) and databases.
  • Ability to import attachments of articles to CDN or WordPress media library.
  • Browser caching through Cache-Control general-header field .
  • Fully mobile support.
  • Caching for search results and database objects.
  • Support CDN.
READ  The Stages Of Seo Content Development

There are many advantages of W3 Total Cache that WP Super Cache does not have. First of all, the paid version also supports Secure Socket Layer (SSL) certificates , helping to increase the security of your data cached. SSL certificates also play a big role in improving SEO .

As mentioned above, many advanced features of W3 Total Cache can insert scripts into Accelerated Mobile Pages (AMP). It ensures optimal site performance for mobile devices.

Finally, we also note that the main strength of W3 Total Cache lies in the pre-caching feature. You can easily adjust before caching will take place where, on disk or on memory .

Now let’s take a look at WP Super Cache. Some of its main features are:

  • Ability to write mod_rewrite for static caching (especially faster than HTML caching based on PHP)
  • Automatically compress pages.
  • Timer cache basic function.
  • Support CDN.
  • The user-friendly export feature makes it easy to copy caching configuration to another site.
  • Mobile device support.

WP Super Cache has some advantages to overcome W3 Total Cache in some other important areas. As such, you can configure to replace the WordPress plugin’s download order. That means you can prioritize the most important plugins for users, to increase the page experience, and user experience throughout the process.

However, with this round of W3 Total Cache vs WP Super Cache, we saw the victory in favor of W3 Total Cache. Although the features may seem too much, if properly configuring your site will significantly increase performance. Particularly important if you are building an e-commerce site or e-commerce business.


Although WP Super Cache is a powerful WordPress cache plugin, capable of handling sites with large traffic, it’s completely free. WP Super Cache also consistently ranks high among WordPress cache plugins, it is a good choice if you don’t have a lot of money but still need a usable solution.

The free version of W3 Total Cache has a number of good features, and a scalable framework. It is fully compatible with performance boosting software such as  Cloudflare and New Relic, as well as WPML plugin (allows to quickly translate into other languages)

W3 Total Cache Pro ($ 99 price) has many other advanced features:

  • Fragment caching. It caches part for a dynamic site (for example, an e-commerce site’s product page)
  • Exclusive extension framework: 3rd party can contribute and fix site errors, without accessing the source code. In return, this can make the site extremely light, significantly increasing overall performance.
  • Genesis Framework compatibility: W3 Total Cache Pro can perform decentralized caching for this extremely popular WordPress theme , increasing load efficiency by 60%.

The other perks of using W3 Total Cache Pro’s paid version are, users can purchase special services for this plugin. Includes features like performance monitoring, service error correction, and plugin configuration services. Prices for these solutions range from $ 250 to $ 350.

When comparing the WP Super Cache vs. W3 Total Cache in terms of cost, the best option depends on what your WordPress site is. If you run a simple site to promote services, need less interaction with customers, WP Super Cache has been sufficient for effective caching roles.

However, if your site ( or multisite system ) has many different e-commerce features, you need to invest in caching fragmentation with an effective solution. W3 Total Cache Pro is for you. It is also the perfect choice for those who want to increase the overall performance of the site with CDN  mirroring .


Support is a factor to consider when choosing the caching WordPress plugin. Usually, it is difficult to determine which features will be most needed for your site (especially if you do not have technical knowledge).

READ  10 Plugin WordPress Gratis Terbaik

Both WP Super Cache and W3 Total Cache are well supported, so you don’t have to worry about this problem. In addition to having a support community from WordPress.org , both have a very detailed and complete FAQ area.

Take a look at the WP Super Cache support interface. Once activated, you will see the Need Help menu showing up:

WP Super Cache Need Help?

In this menu, you can see the instructions for the plugin. In addition to the FAQ page and support forum, you also have your own Debug Tab . This feature lets you type your IP address to debug the plugin, and can help you delete the data cache when an error occurs.

WordPress.org page for WP Super Cache also contains a lot of effective configuration information. If there are no special requirements related to caching for your stie, then please configure it according to the instructions above.

Because W3 Super Cache has more advanced features than WP Super Cache, FAQ pages and support forums are also more powerful. There are many online tutorials to help optimize your WordPress site completely.

When you start exploring how to configure W3 Super Cache, you may have difficulty because of its complexity. To help you solve this problem, the plugin supports Premium Support Response (although the price is quite harsh, up to $ 250).

Comparison between WP Super Cache vs W3 Total Cache on support issues, W3 Total Cache supports better. Although you have to pay for premium support, the W3 total cache helps you solve complex problems quickly and safely. It also has a free version for you to submit bug reports.

WP Super Cache vs W3 Total Cache: Final conclusion

Choose WordPress cache plugin that suits your site’s needs. It is closely related to the complexity and size of the site. So in order to compare, the repository also offers which plugin results are superior to any plugin.

In terms of functionality, support, features and compatibility with performance boosting software, the W3 Total Cache is completely overwhelming. However, if you need a simple, reliable and free solution (but also integrated CDN), WP super cache is the best choice.

We also note that another advantage of W3 Total Cache compared to WP Super Cache is compatibility. W3 Total Cache seems to work with all web hosts and themes, WP has errors related to both problems.

But if you have to choose between the Super Super Cache and W3 Total Cache, we will choose W3 Total Cache – if you have time to get used to its features.


As you can see, if you want full control of your site’s caching capabilities, by configuring details of W3 Total Cache for you. If you want a simple, free tool and can install and run right away, WP Super Cache is a bad choice.

Do you have any questions about WP Super Cache vs W3 Total Cache? Let us know in the comment section below!

Read more :
Compare WP Super Cache vs W3 Total Cache

When developing an effective WordPress website with good conversion capabilities, speed is extremely important. In fact, the user will immediatel

Editor's Rating:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *